Why is water holy?

it is specially blessed

Holy water is just water that has been blessed. Its supposed to clease you from sin or somethin along those lines

It’s not that water is holy. Holy Water is water that is blessed by a priest & used in different rituals.

In the ancient world, water was mystical because of how critical it is to life.

one bretheren told me that water is holy because it can listen…he gave an example saying when you curse water it can actually hear…

um I dont actually know the answer but I can guess. I think it might be because water is the most pure thing you can get? I dunno :/ you could ask at your local church? lol

normal water that is blessed. AKA normal water that a man (who believes he can talk to non-existent beings) talked too.

its just normal water there is nothing holy or magical about it

its just tap water blessed by a vicar

toadaly is closest. Holy water is a perpetuated idea from traditions in many pre-Christian cultures. Think about how difficult it is to find parasite-free water in rural Africa today and remember that’s how it was for most of the world before we learned to boil it. In the earliest religious traditions, communication with the gods was a sacred process and demanded cleanliness (not required by the ordinary people!) There are relic baths and bowls for this purpose in many Greek, Roman & Egyptian temple ruins, and also in pre-10th century West African sacred spaces, e.g. Benin. Springs were consecrated as sacred across pre-Roman Europe. The religious labels may have changed, but the rituals and concepts have not. The earliest references are Sumerian, but I’d guess even their ideas are derived from our earliest African ancestors experiences before they migrated as far as Europe.

Another thought. Many of our early beliefs get captured in art and language. The art of finding hidden springs is still called divining - that’s a relic usage from a time when all new fresh water sources were regarded as sacred and the seeker was a diviner - a valued role in early tribes. There are still many springs around the world where the locals hang offerings, bits of cloth etc in perpetuation of ancient traditions of gratitude. We take fresh water for granted now and no longer bless it (=give thanks) routinely.