Who would win this custody battle?

I’m 22. My ex-girlfriend, Maria, is 24. My son, Lucian, is five.

I currently have Lucian. He’s been with me since she cheated on me with my brother. I let him choose who he wanted to stay with.

Seeing as Maria raised him for five years, I felt awful keeping him from her and I actually set up dates for him to spend the night at her house. She thanked me by hitting him, telling him he doesn’t really love her and saying that he’s a selfish little brat. He called me, crying, while she was pounding on the bathroom door, screaming at him to come out. I have an ‘09 Cobalt SS. I was at the house before she got into the bathroom.

I should clarify that I’d never seen her hit him before and I really didn’t think she would abuse him. I had never imagined it. Later, he told me stories about how badly she’d abuse him for the four and a half years before I knew he existed.

She left bruises on him. He insisted that he never wanted to see her, again. We left it at that. He’s terrified of her. He rightfully feels safer, here.

Maria insists that she deserves custody of Lucian because she is his mother and every child needs a mother.

In court, her case will be my mental instability. I’ve spent over a week in mental lockup. I’ve been known to wake up from nightmares with severe scratches all over myself from my own fingernails. I’ve severely mutilated myself in the past. I have also been diagnosed with severe Obsessive Compulsive Disorder.

My record has been very clear since I broke up with Maria. I’m actually dating a psychologist and he makes an absolutely fantastic boyfriend. (I’m not “bi.” I was strictly in denial before I met him and I have never been happier. I am gay and I finally know it.)

I have never harmed Lucian and I’ve never felt more stable in my life. I’m simply terrified of how my record is going to effect me in court (if she ever coughs up the money for a lawyer.)

Will Lucian’s opinion count? I realize that he’s only five, but he’s very capable of making his own decisions and he knows very well that Maria scares him.

Answer #1

I dont think your son is going to be able to talk in court. I was never able to when I was young either .simply because it is very easy to manipulate a child into saying something that isnt true. I am not saying that you did do that but that is how the courts think of it. As for your mental state of mind that could effect the court or it could not. it just depends on all the negative stuff that your ex has to say about you and what the courts believe. And since you werent there in your childs life for 4 1/2 years they are gonna be thinking about that too. And if she is hurting the child in any way then the child needs to go talk to some one like a police officer or something right after he comes back from his moms house. And if there are marks on him you need to take pictures of it in her house so you can show the courts. Dont let her mess your life up. He is your child and you deserve to be around him. I hope this helped if you have any other questions about it fun mail me

More Like This

Parents & Family

Parenting, Marriage, Childcare

Ask an advisor one-on-one!

Maples Family Law

Divorce Law, Child Custody, Family Law

Jos Family Law

Family Law, Child Custody, Legal Services

Sugarlight - family & materni...

Photography, Family Services, Maternity Services

Forge Legal

Family Law, Business Law, Wills & Estates

Family Divorce Lawyer

Legal Services, Family Law, Divorce Lawyer