My son wants to be a girl

at such a young age its impossible to tell if its just a faze or if he actually beleives he should have been born as a woman instead of a man while its not exactly common for this to happen its not too rare either there are other children abnd adults out there who becleive they were born as the wrong gender now what your son actually thinks will be hard for both you and him to understand untill hes a bit older discourage him from cutiing off his penis because thats mutilation and not the right way to go about it if he did want to be a woman and try to accept it make sure you dont go around calling him a freak, saying its a sin, ect but tell him that he doesnt have to decide now try to get him tio understand that when hes older is the best time to fully mak the decision, when hes had a long think about what he wnants to be in the meantime, get him involved with both male and female activities, sports, toys, movies, ect try to offer him the best of both worlds ( of being male and female) which will help him make up his mind more and sometiomes kids at a very young age do beleive they were born as the wrong gender and unless horrible parents force them to be and act “normal” then they will usualluy continue to beleive it for the rest of there life when hes older and if he still wants to be a female, just be loving and supportive and try to accept him and not let it get in the way of your relationship weather your the mother of the father of your son, its not something that you should stop loving him for

Sigh. Ignorance is amazing and yet so sad. How is giving him a car or a football going to help?

Right now there’s not much you can do except giving him unconditional acceptance… Like filetospam said, it could be a temporary fascination, or a phase, or it could be an actual gender identity thing, and he could be transgender (and for the uneducated who dont know the difference between sexual orientation and gender identity, perhaps you need to do some reading before you open your mouth).

I’d read up on it a bit… if you need more support, try a counselor, or a support group… kids have enough to deal with from outsiders without having their parents treat them like they’re mistakes… http://abcnews.go.com/2020/story?id=3088298 http://www.lauras-playground.com/transgender_transsexual_children.htm http://www.transkidspurplerainbow.org/

No telling at this point if this is just a fascination, phase, or gender confusion.

You need to be loving, accepting, and patient regardless.

There is an interesting French film, Ma vie en rose deals with this specific issue. A boy who believes he was supposed to be a girl.

Thanks for your answers, but nearly 5 years is a long time for a phase! He doesnt get attention from this, as I tend to just carry on as normal. I’ve tried football, karate..allsorts. Only yesterday he told me he wanted to chop his ‘winky’ off!!! I just dont know what to do next!

It is probably just a phase… he doesn’t understand, he is probably just saying it and doing it because he gets attention from it, and he probably thinks it is funny. He’ll grow out of it probably, everyone goes through weird phases.

:)

5 years is a long time for a phase. he might be gender confused, and that does not mean he is gay. just be supportive,and loving. let him be who he wants to be.

its pretty commen like suckin a pacafier(if your american) dummy (europe) till a late stage.! he will eventually grow out of it. try takin him 2 a football game are something buy him a few small toys lke cars. that shud help him out on the way. please rate me.!

well I dont think it smart to worrying about it untill hes older so just wait untill he a little older and even if he still wants to be a girl just rember :

a father would be ofended a father would push him to be a boy a father would hate him for being who he is but a true DAD would love him no matter what !! ^^

u definately do not want to yell at him or tell him sumthing is wrong with him. you cant ignore it either. you have to make him feel normal regardless because he will get ridiculed in school and by society. but if that is who he is then love him how he is. you have to be the only one who never turns your back on him. take him 2 counseling or therapy. There are movies about this sort of stuff. rent a movie or two. he is too young 2 understand so he needs your help.

You are his mommy. You give him lots and lots of hugs. You tell him as often as you can that you love him. You support him in everyway that you know how to. Even if it’s hard. You don’t encourage. You don’t discourage. He may grow out of this. He may not. If you always show him love then he will always feel love for himself.

if he wants to be a girl thats his personnel choice would you hate him if he was gay? if you say yes then your a horrible monster for hating you own son if you said no… then what’s the problem?? ps. ask him why. maybe he really just wants to have long hair or… oooh! maybe he thinks their pretty and want to be pretty and doesn’t know that he can be handsome!

if he prefers disney princesses over power rangers then you just might have to except the fact that he is gay