Which is your favourite peanut butter to put on a sandwich - creamy, crunchy, or extra crunchy?

It depends on the kind of peanutbutter. When it comes to JIFF peanut butter, I like using a strawberry jam, it goes well together because JIFF isn’t TOO sweet, but just sweet enough.

However, Peterpan is REALLY sweet, and I like to pair it with a berry, preferably a more tart one, kind of jam.

I don’t like crunchy on anything but toast.

AND ONLY PETER PAN PENUT BUTTER!

My favorite is skippy reduced fat chunky peanut butter. I love pairing it with apple butter or strawberry jam on rye bread!

Toast with crunchy honey roasted peanuts! (Peter Pan of course)

creamy peanut butter, with grape jelly

It’s peanut not penut

YOU KNEW WHAT I MEANT

Dang, you’ve got it down to a science!

creamy =D but I love regular peanuts aswell

Ew :S I’ve never eaten a PB & J sandwich. However, if I HAD to choose…it would be creamy.

Crunchy! :D

Extra crunchy.

I like crunchy peanut butter, cause it’s fun… lmao but I like it best with honey.

I like natural peanut butter; the kind with nothing but peanuts in it. I like Smucker’s natural peanut butter best so far. I generally get the creamy for sandwiches but crunchy is nice on toast. My favorite peanut butter sandwich is peanut butter and apricot preserves on wheat.

extra crunchy skippy!

Creamy and I use strawberry jelly or grade jelly. I like peanut butter and banana too.

Creamy and I use strawberry jelly or grade jelly. I like peanut butter and banana too.

Don’t like peanutbutter:O

CREAMYY is wayyyy much better.!