How do I convince my mom to let me move with my dad to Idaho?

Background Information:

My parents are divorced and have been since the summer of 2011. I live with my 7 year old little sister and my mother at my aunts house in Washington (state). Both of my parents are homeless. My mom lives with her sister and my dad lives in the living room of a 2 bedroom apartment with 2 roommates (also in Washington about a 45 minute drive away). My sister and I see my dad every other weekend and some holidays every other year.

Problem:

I get along with both of my parents very well in different ways, but lately I’ve been thinking of moving to (Moscow) Idaho with my dad. My mom said that if my little sister came with me she would be fine because she does not want us to be separated. My dad was of course totally fine with it but he even told me that my mom would not give up both kids. He says that I’m old enough (14 years old) to make my own decisions and that Victoria (my sister) should be able to say where she wants to live. I asked my little sister what she thought about moving and showed her the house (One that we would have to our selves) we would live in and she was up for the idea. She told my mom that she wanted to move with us and although I wasn’t there for the whole conversation I over heard a few things.. My mom convinced my sister to stay by making her feel bad. My mother is very ‘passive aggressive’ (1 reason I would like to get away from her) and told my sister things like, “You’re going to cry every night if you go. Why would you make a stupid decision like that?” “If you go I’m going to be crying all the time, I’m going to miss you so much.” “I just want to make everyone happy. If you think you’ll be happy then fine I wont stop you.” And when my sister gave in my mom said things like “By law you aren’t even allowed to go.” When you are both 18 you can go do whatever you want, but I’m not letting my kids go anywhere until then.” Hearing all of this makes me want to go even more. I knew Victoria wanted to stay with her mommy anyways and I think its for the best. I know that If I talk to my mom about it, she wont let me go. It’s just going to create an argument that I wont win because of how sensitive and empathetic I am. I know it’ll hurt her if I go and I wont be able to argue with her when she eventually starts crying. I hate that she uses my feelings against me. How do you think I can make her come to her senses and convince her that it’ll make me happy? Should I write a letter? Or tell her straight up and try to win an argument? Trying to just ‘Tell her how I feel’ Isn’t going to work and I already know that.

Why I want to move:

  • My little sister and I fight a lot at home and if we split I feel like we would be closer. ‘Distance makes the heart fonder’
  • When living with my dad I feel as if I will have more chances to be more independent, learn new things, and be open to new experiences.
  • I miss having my own place to live. Somewhere where I can actually call home and be myself at. I’m also at an age where I think I could really use a new room instead of sharing with a 7 year old or sleeping on the living room floor/couch.
  • I hate the place I’m living. I want to go to the country side and just get out of the city. I hate the school and the weather and absolutely everything. I want to start over in a new place and at a new school. I want to make new friends and create new memories.

I love my mom very much as well as my sister and dad, but I’m just not happy here. How do I tell my mom this? Can I really not leave with my dad by law? I cry every night just thinking about it. I know I probably wont be able to help it but don’t want to hurt my mom, friends, and/or family but I’m just not happy here… What can I do? What should I say?

Sorry for all of that typing^^ lol -Thanks.

Answer #1

by the sound of things, It looks like you have put a lot of thought into this.

But it also sounds that you may be only thinking about yourself which is never good when you are thinking about doing this. I suggest you try to think of all the reasons why your parents say what they say.

You should try and show this letter to your mother first of all. Since you are putting all your thoughts on paper “per say” it wont cause you to stumble on your thoughts and make you sound more mature.

Like I said before, think of what your parents are thinking. At first glands it sounds like your mother doesn’t trust your father enough to properly take care of you. Especially if you said that if he thinks that you are old enough to make your own decisions. It sounds more like he will let you do what you want but wont watch over you to make sure you are doing things right.

Also, it’s a matter of living conditions. you need to remember that whether you live in the city, in the countryside, or in space, as long as you have a roof on top of your head, everything else is a luxury and luxuries are expandable and not important. For example, if your father were to be living in the city close by with your mother, would this really make a difference??

siblings are always going to fight. even if you do move. it is life.

you could live with your father but be aware that if that happens there is more governmental paper work to prove he could provide for you. and since he lives with roommates, It could go either way.

change does hurt. I’m not trying to prevent you from going and im sorry if this was not what you wanted to hear. your family comes first. you are going to hurt your mother as much as you may already hurt your father when you are not there. But I believe it hurts more when one does things without thinking about all the factors in this kind of situation.

I wish you well in your future decisions.

-calderoh

More Like This
Advisor

Parents & Family

Parenting, Marriage, Childcare

Ask an advisor one-on-one!
Advisor

2 Dads with Baggage

Family Travel, LGBT Travel, Parenting Blog

Advisor

2 Dads with Baggage

LGBT family travel blog, Parenting blog, Travel blog

Advisor

Being Mom and More

Parenting, Pregnancy, Books

Advisor

Baby Bath Moments

Parenting, Child Care, Health & Safety

Advisor

Petrelli Law

Divorce Law, Family Law, Legal Services