Can you ever be friends with someone you love?

When I was about 16 years old, I started dating this guy. It ended as most relationships at that age do, and after awhile we lost touch with one another. 5 years pass, and one day I find that he has tracked me down on facebook, we exchange a few emails, and he begins telling me how he has spent the last 5 years of his life wanting to be with me, comparing girlfriends to me.How he always remembered how happy I made him. How he wanted to grow old, and gray with me. This goes on for about 2 months, (currently I am living a few states away.) Finally I decide to fly down to see him, and I could instantly tell that something was not right from the momment he picked me up, but just thought he was nervous, so continued on. He later ends up telling me that hes just not ready for a relationship, that he just got out of one, and thought it was what he wanted, but as soon as he saw me it was a big jolt of reality to him, but he didnt want to loose me out of his life again, and wanted to remain friends. This was 2 months ago. He has since posted on his facebook page pictures of him, and his new girlfriend.who is a lot younger than him, and has a child. he lied to me when I asked him about her, he said they we’re just friends. but when he found out I was moving back home, then he decided to come clean and, according to him, he wasn’t looking for a girlfriend, it just sorta happend. Now we are trying to be friends, but its like he, and I have swapped places. Now I’ m the one thinking about him. hes been trying to call me for the last few days, to talk about all this. I just don’t know what to say to him. I’ m pissed off, but at the same time I want to have him in my life. Am I an idiot? can you really be friends with someone you love? How could he have said the things that he did to me, and then just have it all go away?

Answer #1

Wow. He really messed with your mind! It sounds like he was not with someone, looked you up, fed you full of crap how it’s been you and only you for 5 years in his mind, and then hooked up with someone else that came along. It’s happened to all of us in different ways.

While I don’t think the kid purposefully played with your heart, he really disrespected you by telling those lies. He just wanted to get you where he wanted you. Once he got you there, ooops, he wasn’t really serious. He thought he was, but he wasn’t.

Really, what’s the point of being friends here? Every realtionship should serve you in some capacity. You have a purpose for the person and they have a purpose for you. What would be his purpose for you, besides to remind you of the pain and anger he made you feel by playing with your emotions?

And YOU KNOW that if things fail with this new girl, that he will be all up in your Kool aid again, saying whatever he has to to get you back where he wants you. If you stayed friends with him, you would become his “Last Resort Girl”. And I’d rather be alone than to be anyone’s LRG.

With friends like him, who needs friends, right? The sucky thing is that he didn’t need to go on and on overboard with the “oh, it’s only been you and only you for years and years” bullcrap. He could have just asked how you were doing and see how it went.

He’s only going to hurt you.

Answer #2

You CANNOT be friends with someone you love. You will always misinterpret every little thing he does, thinking he feels the same way back. If my ex ever came looking for me 5 yrs down the road…i would have to say id probably turn the other cheek! Only because of everything hes put me through.

Youre not an idiot…he sort of lead you on. How were you to know how things really were with him. If he cant even be honest with you..he just isnt worth it. Maybe he said those things to you, because at the time him and his gf werent doing very well. Who knows…i still havent figured out my ex yet, and i probably never will, but im not ever gonna give him the opportunity again!

As hard as it may be…leave him exactly where he has been the past 5 yrs….behind you. I think you’ll be so much better off! Sounds like he has alot of baggage anyway!

Good Luck!

Answer #3

This guy is a d*ck and a bad example. But you can absolutely be friends with someone you love. My girlfriend and I have been dating for 10 months now and she is without a doubt my best friend.

In fact, I’d even argue that friendship is the key to a real relationship. I trust her completely and I know I can talk to her about anything, even stuff that most would find awkward to talk to their girlfriend about. If this guy’s getting with a young girl with a baby, he has problems of his own and could never be there for you like a friend should be.

More Like This
Advisor

Love & Relationships

Dating, Marriage, Breakups

Ask an advisor one-on-one!
Advisor

The Love Always Project

Funeral Services, Death Planning, End-of-Life Education

Advisor

Trusted Readings from Love Ps...

Psychic Readings, Love Advice, Relationship Guidance

Advisor

Sameer Sulemani ji Love Marri...

Love Marriage Specialist, Astrology Services, Family Counseling

Advisor

Love Bird Ceremonies

Marriage Celebrants, Wedding Services, Event Planning Services