Infinite possibility or finite possibility?

One of the fun things I used to contemplate when I was not paying enough attention to the courses I was taking in college was the concept of infinity. And the concept of zero.

Mathematically speaking, you can’t calculate either value - you can approach zero, and you can approach infinity, but you can’t actually get to either one. In a universe of infinity, for example, is there anything that exists outside of that infinity? I would say, no, because by virtue of having an observer in the universe of infinity, you allow for measurement - something which infinity can’t hold to, eg, inifinity by it’s nature is innumerable.

So that brings me to zero. You can’t have “zero quarters” because it’s the lack of quarters you are describing - eg, there is a quarter out there, somewhere, you just don’t have one. And, you can’t have in hand, zero dollars - somewhere, there is a dollar, and the concept is there. It’s not a measure of a dollar, if you have “zero dollars” it’s a lack of dollars, that you are referring to, not zero.

Thus if you have a dollar, break it into pennies, and then cut the pennies into their smallest parts, you still have fractions of money…you can’t arrive at zero money, b/c you have the atoms, protons, nuetrons, and electrons that made up that money, and then further on, you have the quarks, leptons, etc, that made up those atoms.

Where does this leave us? I don’t know :) I should have studied more math…however, I’d be interested in your take. Is zero equivalent to infinity? If not, why not? And if they are equivalent, mathematically speaking, then why aren’t they taught as such in schools? And if they aren’t equivalent, two aspects of the same concept, then what’s the flaw in my reasoning?

Answer #1

Well… zero is not actually a number, it is simply a simple definintion of nothingness. Also, just for brain fodder, if zero represents nothing and infinite is all. How can infinite to the power or zero still equal one and each would cancel each other out? Everything powerd by nothing is still something?

Answer #2

lilykatt: Zero is a number. It’s part of the natural numbers, the rationals, etc.

You can’t raise infinity to a power, because infinity is not a number - the comparison is meaningless.

Answer #3

I think they’re opposite. Zero represents a lack of anything and infinity represents everything and then some. Zero is the wrong word used sometimes. How about I have ‘no’ money.

Answer #4

no… just look at a number line… zero is deffinatley a reachable number. its impossible to mathematically reach infinity, but theres “infinite” ways to mathematically reach zero.

I dont get your money analogy… of course you can have zero money, its also known as being bankrupt lol.

Answer #5

They’re inversely related, rather than the same thing.

You might be interested in a field known as transfinite math. Rigorous proofs have been done that show actual infinities are possible.

Answer #6

weell zero and infinity are unreal numbersso we are decribing something we dont really know is there(imaginary only nessessary to peak curiosity of somthing we dont understand.kind of like describing figuratively.u are blue in the face,the face isnt really blue but you still understand the concept of the point trying to be displayed) everything between however are real numbers that have a value that can be mathematically explained.the reason for your confusion is you are comparing apples to oranges not apples to apples.and they do teach that in school now.I learned it in high school but you wouldnt believe there teaching that to middle school and elementary kids now times are changin and kids are getting too smart for there own good.that was a really good question though.keep em coming

Answer #7

I believe, yes, they are. and from my knowledge I think teaching kids something that time consuming would confuse far too many.

same as them saying cristopher columbus discovered america, when we all learn YEARS later he did not.

it’s all really a matter of how you think about it.

Answer #8

A few points:

  • You can ‘calculate’ zero. 2-2=0, for example. You can’t divide two positive integers and get zero, though - perhaps that’s what you’re alluding to? Zero is an odd number, though. Check out http://scienceblogs.com/goodmath/2006/07/zero.php for an excellent summary.
  • Infinity is not a number (zero is). You’re right that you can’t ‘calculate’ infinity insofar as that you can’t sum a finite number of finite values and get infinity. Again, though, infinity isn’t a number - you can’t do math with it (infinity / 2 is not a valid equation. nor is infinity - 1).
  • What you touch on with the idea of “zero dollars”, etcetera, is what used to be a fairly fundamental rift in mathematics. Back in the 18th century (my timing may be off), there was a great deal of disagreement over whether or not math had any validity beyond how it reflects the physical world. In a purely physical sense, you’re right that the idea of “0 quarters” does not make a great deal of sense. But then, neither does “negative 4 apples”, but we generally accept the ‘fiction’ of negative numbers due to their convenience. This argument was mostly resolved with the advent of computers, which suddenly provided a concrete use for formal logic and a bunch of other areas that previously seemed like “second class math”, and mathematicians now generally agree that math has meaning above and beyond how we map it to the real world.
  • It is still meaningful to assign units to a zero value, however. “0 dollars” is different from “0 apples”, because “0 dollars + 5 dollars” is a valid sum (preserving units), and “0 apples + 5 dollars” isn’t.
  • Even though infinity isn’t a number, there is more than one magnitude of infinity. These are known as “transfinite numbers”. For example, the natural numbers (1, 2, 3, …) are infinite but countable, while the real numbers (0.1234, 5.38272, etc) aren’t. Even though both are infinite, there’s provably more real numbers than natural numbers! Even stranger, the rational numbers are countable, so there’s exactly as many rational numbers as natural numbers.
More Like This
Advisor

Science

Biology, Chemistry, Physics

Ask an advisor one-on-one!
Advisor

The Top Facts

Science, History, Facts