How can I choose one guy if I love them both?

Hi everyone! My Name Is Ashley and Im in love with two guys. One of their names is Anthony. Anthony and I went out in the 8th grade for 5 months and when he broke it off at the end of the school year I was in complete shock. But when we were together it was great we were so good together. And now Im dating this guy named Taylor. We have been together for 1 yr and almost 3 months. Hes amazing! my entire family loves him and hopes for us to one day get married. By the way Im a junior, Anthony is a junior and Taylor is a sophomore. And Anthony goes to my school but Taylor doesnt. We meet at Wednesday night youth. Taylor and I do everything together and we are perfect for each other! And O yeah his family loves me too. But lately Anthony and I have started talking more and more and that old spark has now become a full burning flame for him again. I just dont know what to do. My dad hates Anthony because he thinks that he called me a whore but he didnt!! And Im just not sure what the rest of my family will think of him. I just dont know what to do. For the past year I have done everything with Taylor… Is it time for me to let go and move on? Or do I let Anthony go and stay with Taylor? Please tell me what you think. Thank you for taking the time to read my problems and for taking the time to answer!

-God Bless,

       Ashley