Should my nine year old sister read the Twilight sereies?

As a mother who HAS read all 4 of the books, I think Twilight and New Moon may be ok —but as for Eclipse and especially Breaking Dawn, I feel neither of those 2 would be appropriate for an 11 year old. I truthfully didn’t feel my 13 year old should have been reading Breaking Dawn. Breaking Dawn was a little to graphic for that kindo work aimed at such a young demographic. The sexual innuendos from Emmett, the overall sexual theme of the entire book once Bella is changed and they move into their little cottage. Books 1 and 2—excellent I would say, but no further until she is 12 or 13, maybe eve 14 for book 4.

yeah you should its not like shes going to go do it lolx

I am not sure that even the first two books are suitable to children under 14ish. There is a Romeo and Juliet theme to the book that a young girl who does not understand love and the lessons learned by failed relationships may take too seriously. Do we really want out young girls hearing and reading things like I DON’T WANT TO LIVE WITHOUT YOU, I WANT TO DIE IF YOU DIE, or what about when Edward goes to Italy trying to get himself killed because he thinks Bella is dead. I think we are setting our young girls up showing them these things before they reached a sense of self.

well my parents felt uncomfortable.. but I loved them to much and I had to read on.. just like everybody else! and my sisters were reading it at the same time..

Yes it is her choice on the books she reads not yours the twilight books are a little mature but no by much. If your sister has not already heard of sex then maybe not but I am pretty sure she knows more than you think.