Is 'A Song of Ice and Fire' an Alternate History story?

Is George R.R. Martin’s epic ‘A Song of Ice and Fire’ an Alternate History story?

Answer #1

It’s not an alternative history that I know of. I read the first book in the series “A Game of Thrones” and was impressed. Unfortunately, I haven’t had time to read the rest of the series.

From what I recall, the northern border issue with the guards that were forced to live in a near endless winter, it doesn’t have any bearing on any history that I know of. You can make similar arguments about “alternative histories” for many fantasy works, which tend to borrow elements from history & folklore to evoke a sense of belonging & provided a grounded point of reference upon which to drape the rest of their fantastical tales. Thanks for posting.

Answer #2

No. You silly mortal.

More Like This
Funadvice Logo

© FUNADVICE 2025 · 212bydesign LLC

Answering questions since 2006

[email protected]

Miami, Florida, USA