How to pick between two great girls?

Who says you’re going to lose one or the other?

Girls send mixed signals ALL the time. Sometimes, if they like a guy, they’ll also try to keep is cool if they’re not sure how he feels. So she might flirt one day and then be buddy-buddy the next day because she doesn’t want to scare you off. That’s not a guarantee that she likes you though, that’s just one theory.

As for Taylor, do you mean she’s promiscuous and cheats on guys? Or does she just have a diff boyfriend every month? Maybe she just hasn’t met a guy she really likes yet. Maybe that will be you. If you think she’s a cheater, you could try to give her the benefit of the doubt, but if you don’t trust her in the first place, the relationship is already doomed.

Either way, if you pick a girl, there’s no rule saying you can’t stay friends with the other. If the relationship gets serious, then it would be difficult to date an ex’s friend, but if you date for a couple weeks and decide it’s not right, it’s not the worst thing in the world to ask out someone you knew before you dated your ex. Just make sure you wait a while before asking out the other. That would just look bad.

Don’t know if that helped at all. Just sharing my thoughts.

Good luck!